
- Verfasst vonPhilip Liebenow
- Veröffentlicht am01.April
- Lesezeit5min
When employers offer a company pension (bAV), they often think first about finding the right provider and the appropriate implementation method. However, one document is frequently underestimated: the pension scheme regulations. Yet, this is the central set of rules that establishes the framework for the company pension in a uniform and binding manner for all employees—protecting the company from avoidable legal and financial risks. This article explains what pension scheme regulations are, what content they should cover, and why companies—regardless of their size—should not go without them.
Auf einen Blick
Legal Framework: The pension scheme regulations are a binding set of rules that collectively define the framework for the company pension, thereby creating transparency and legal certainty for both employers and employees.
Risk Minimization: Without pension scheme regulations, companies face risks such as implied contractual obligations (betriebliche Übung), violations of the principle of equal treatment, or unclear benefit commitments.
Individual Design: The employer independently determines the implementation method, provider, eligibility rules, subsidy levels, and types of benefits.
Professional Drafting: Since the document has far-reaching legal consequences, it should be drafted or reviewed by specialized professionals.
1. What are pension scheme regulations?
Pension scheme regulations (Versorgungsordnung) are an employment law instrument that bindingly establishes the framework for company pensions within a company. As the "legal basis" for the company pension, they define which benefits apply under what conditions for which employees—ensuring that all staff are treated according to uniform criteria.
While pension scheme regulations are not legally required, they are highly recommended in practice as soon as a company offers a company pension—whether through salary sacrifice, employer subsidies, or a fully employer-funded plan. Without written regulations, ambiguities can quickly arise, leading to legal risks. At the same time, professional pension scheme regulations signal to employees that the employer takes retirement planning seriously, which can strengthen the perception of the company pension as a high-value benefit.
You can find out more about the basics of company pensions here.
2. What risks arise without pension scheme regulations?
Without written pension scheme regulations, a company pension operates in a legal gray area. The most common risks include:
Implied contractual obligations (Betriebliche Übung): If an employer grants company pension benefits according to a specific pattern over a long period—such as a specific subsidy—without regulating this in writing, it can create a legal entitlement for all employees. The Federal Labour Court (BAG) has repeatedly ruled that repeating a benefit in the same way three times can establish an implied contractual obligation.
Violation of the principle of equal treatment: The employment law principle of equal treatment requires that employers do not treat comparable employees differently regarding voluntary benefits like company pensions without an objective reason. Those who pay different subsidies to individual employees without clear regulations risk facing claims for back payments.
Unclear benefit commitments: Without written documentation, it may remain unclear which type of commitment applies—specifically, whether the employer has granted a defined benefit commitment, a contribution-oriented defined benefit commitment, or a defined contribution commitment with a minimum benefit. In the event of a claim, this can lead to disputes regarding the amount of the benefit.
Lack of amendment clauses: If a company wishes to adjust its company pension later on—for example, to change the implementation method or the level of subsidies—this is significantly more difficult without corresponding clauses in the pension scheme regulations. If an amendment clause is missing, even stricter labor law hurdles apply.
3. What exactly do pension scheme regulations cover?
Pension scheme regulations should clearly and unambiguously define the central parameters of the company pension. Typical contents include:
Implementation method and provider: The pension scheme regulations specify which of the five statutory implementation methods is used—in practice, direct insurance is the most common method, especially for small and medium-sized enterprises. The specific company pension provider is also named.
Eligible group of persons and access requirements: In principle, all employees have a statutory right to salary sacrifice (§ 1a BetrAVG). The pension scheme regulations also govern whether and under what conditions the employer pays its own subsidies—for example, after a certain period of service or a probationary period. They can also specify which groups of employees are excluded from certain benefits—such as fixed-term employees, working students, or employees on probation. Differentiation based on objective criteria is also possible, for example between different groups of employees. Important: Such differentiation must comply with the General Equal Treatment Act (AGG) and the labor law principle of equal treatment.
Financing and subsidy level: The pension scheme regulations define whether the company pension is funded through salary sacrifice, employer contributions, or a mix of both. They set the level of the employer subsidy—since 2022, a minimum of 15% on converted contributions has been legally required (§ 1a para. 1a BetrAVG). Many companies go beyond this.
Type of commitment: It is determined which type of commitment is made: (pure) defined benefit, defined contribution with minimum benefit (BZML), contribution-oriented defined benefit (BOLZ), or pure defined contribution (rBZ—currently only in social partner models).
Scope of benefits: In addition to the old-age pension, the pension scheme regulations can also contain provisions for disability and survivor benefits.
Handling of existing and newly joining employees: The pension scheme regulations should set out how to handle employees who already have company pension contracts from previous employment relationships, and under what conditions new employees are included in the company pension. This creates clarity for HR teams and avoids case-by-case decisions.
Periods without remuneration: Especially with employer-funded company pensions, it is important to define what happens during periods without remuneration—such as during parental leave, long-term illness, or sabbaticals. Are contribution payments continued, suspended, or made on a pro-rata basis during these phases? Without clear regulations, inconsistent handling and potential equal treatment issues can easily arise.
Provisions upon departure: The pension scheme regulations should specify the options available to employees when changing jobs: premium-free continuation, transfer to a new employer, or continuation as a private insurance policy.
4. How are pension scheme regulations implemented in a company?
The implementation of pension scheme regulations is governed by labor law. The signed document is either posted on the company notice board or intranet, or provided individually as an attachment to employment contracts. Under labor law, this is sufficient to establish its legal validity.
Additional requirement under the Proof of Employment Act: According to the simplified version of the Proof of Employment Act effective from January 1, 2025, the pension scheme regulations must also be sent to all employees individually in text form – for example, via email with the document as a PDF attachment. The employer must request confirmation of receipt. Important: The request for confirmation is sufficient – actual confirmation from the employees is not required. If the employer has already provided the pension scheme regulations to all employees in paper form with a handwritten signature, the additional electronic transmission requirement does not apply.
5. What should employers keep in mind when drafting the document?
Pension scheme regulations are a document with far-reaching legal consequences. Errors or gaps can be costly – whether due to unintended benefit claims, missing amendment clauses, or violations of the principle of equal treatment.
Therefore, it is essential that the drafting process be supported by specialized experts. Many company pension brokers now assist employers in creating legally secure pension scheme regulations (often based on template documents).
Furthermore, it is advisable to review the pension scheme regulations regularly – especially in the event of legislative changes, a change of company pension provider, or significant changes in the company structure.
Conclusion: Pension scheme regulations create clarity – for everyone involved
Pension scheme regulations are not just a bureaucratic "nice-to-have," but an essential management tool for company pensions. They create transparency for employees, legal certainty for the employer, and enable a consistent, comprehensible approach to company pensions throughout the entire company. Anyone introducing or already offering a company pension should not delay the creation of professional pension scheme regulations.
Wir machen darauf aufmerksam, dass die Inhalte unserer Internetseite (auch etwaige Rechtsbeiträge) lediglich dem unverbindlichen Informationszweck dienen und keine Rechtsberatung im eigentlichen Sinne darstellen. Der Inhalt dieser Informationen kann und soll eine individuelle und verbindliche Rechtsberatung, die auf Ihre spezifische Situation eingeht, nicht ersetzen. Insofern verstehen sich alle bereitgestellten Informationen ohne Gewähr auf Richtigkeit, Vollständigkeit und Aktualität.


